Songs for Your Concert: Classic Favorites and Underrated Gems
Songs for Your Concert: Classic Favorites and Underrated Gems
November 5th, 2025
Previously, we focused on 10 classic songs proven to be fan favorites at a holiday concert. They were timeless songs that everyone knows.
This year, we suggest 10 songs that will challenge the band and capture the audience, songs that haven’t had the same attention. Some are popular, but by no means easy. Some are incredibly underrated. All in a wide range of skill sets, depending on the desired complexity.
The holiday season is the perfect time for high school bands to showcase their talent and spread festive cheer. Choosing the right repertoire is essential to captivate audiences, create a memorable concert experience, and highlight the musicians’ abilities. Here are some of the most recommended and underrated holiday songs, Christmas songs, and concert songs that deserve a spot in your upcoming holiday program:
Most Recommended Songs for High School Bands:
1. Sleigh Ride by Leroy Anderson
History & Why to Play: Composed in 1948, “Sleigh Ride” has become a quintessential Christmas song recognized by all. Its lively, joyful tempo and iconic horse whinny make it a crowd-pleaser, showcasing the band’s precision and energy.
Find it here.
2. A Christmas Festival by Leroy Anderson
History & Why to Play: This medley, arranged by Leroy Anderson, blends several traditional carols into one seamless concert song. It’s a staple in holiday concerts for its variety, dynamic transitions, and appeal to audiences of all ages.
Find it here.
3. Carol of the Bells by Mykola Leontovych/arr. Sean O’Loughlin
History & Why to Play: Originally a Ukrainian folk chant, “Carol of the Bells” was arranged in 1914 and has become a dramatic Christmas song favorite. Its cascading motifs and haunting rhythm offer an opportunity to showcase the band’s tight coordination and dynamic control.
Find it here.
4. Frosty the Snowman arr. Michael Story
History & Why to Play: This fun and light-hearted holiday song brings nostalgia and warmth to any concert. Arranged for high school bands, it engages the audience with its upbeat tempo and familiar tune.
Find it here.
5. The Polar Express Medley by Alan Silvestri/arr. Jerry Brubaker
History & Why to Play: From the beloved holiday film, this medley captures the magic and excitement of the story. It’s perfect for showcasing both the band’s musical range and the holiday spirit that connects with younger and older audiences alike.
Find it here.
Underrated Gems for Your Holiday Concert:
1. Patapan arr. Shelley Hanson
History & Why to Play: This 17th-century French carol offers an infectious rhythm with a distinct percussive drive. Its playful character and unique instrumentation make it stand out as an exciting Christmas song, adding variety and a touch of European folk flavor to the concert.
Find it here.
2. A Most Wonderful Christmas arr. Robert Sheldon
History & Why to Play: This medley combines several beloved holiday songs in a smooth, flowing arrangement that can be overlooked. It challenges the band to transition seamlessly between styles and tempos, enhancing their versatility.
Find it here.
3. On This Day Earth Shall Ring arr. Gustav Holst
History & Why to Play: Holst’s arrangement of this medieval carol adds a touch of historical elegance with its rich, complex harmonies. This concert song can showcase the band’s expressive abilities, bringing depth and a solemn, reflective moment to the holiday concert.
Find it here.
4. Celtic Carol arr. Robert W. Smith
History & Why to Play: This spirited arrangement blends traditional Celtic sounds with holiday themes, creating a lively and memorable performance. The piece’s rhythmic drive and unique instrumentation provide an exciting contrast to standard Christmas songs.
Find it here.
5. Gaudete arr. Brian Beck
History & Why to Play: “Gaudete” is a lively medieval carol transformed into a vibrant concert band arrangement. Its bright, rhythmic energy is fun for students to play, pleasantly surprises audiences with its lesser-known charm, and adds a fresh, festive twist to any holiday program.
Find it here.
Conclusion:
Incorporating both well-known Christmas songs and holiday songs along with underrated pieces can make your high school band’s holiday concert truly special. Favorites like “Sleigh Ride” and “The Polar Express Medley” draw the audience in with familiarity, while hidden gems such as “Patapan” and “Gaudete” add variety and depth, showcasing the band’s range and artistry. Make your next holiday concert unforgettable with these selections!
Get weekly tips to make your events better. Subscribe here:
